Meldung 51 (NO-1128): Difference between revisions

From CODOH Forum Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older editNewer edit →
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
== Summary ==
A single Nazi document—Meldung Nr. 51 (29 December 1942, Nuremberg NO-1128)<ref>Trials of War Criminals before the Nuernberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10, Nuernberg, October 1946-April 1949, pp. 269-272</ref>—is often cited as ironclad proof of the Holocaust: 363,211 "Jews executed" in four months across "Russland-Süd, Ukraine, Bialystok." Historians like Raul Hilberg and Yitzhak Arad link it to the near-total murder of ~300,000 Jews in Ukraine's Volhynia-Podolia region.<ref>Hilberg 2003, Vol. III, p.1312; Arad 2009, p.263 (Mattogno, The Einsatzgruppen, pp.252-253)</ref> But scrutinize its military framing, demographics, and logic: this is an exaggerated tally of Eastern Front anti-partisan operations targeting Soviet irregulars and suspected Jewish collaborators—not a racial extermination ledger.<ref>Mattogno, The Einsatzgruppen, pp.252-259</ref> Part of ~80 "Reports to the Führer on Bandit-Fighting," it reflects brutal total war, not premeditated genocide.


Meldung 51/NO-1128 is a document purportedly detailing orders from Himmler to Hitler regarding the execution of 363,211 Jews in General Commissariat Volhynia-Podolia in 1942. The authenticity of this document has been questioned, with some suggesting that the word "exekutiert" (executed) might be a misinterpretation of "evakuiert" (evacuated). The reported figure of 363,211 executions in this region during a short period in 1942 is considered unrealistic by early Holocaust researcher Gerald Reitlinger, who acknowledged it as a "manifest exaggeration."<ref>[Gerald Reitlinger, "The Final Solution: The Attempt to Exterminate the Jews of Europe 1939-45," Jason Aronson, 1987, p. 226, originally published 1953]</ref>
== Military Context: Partisan War, Not Civilian Slaughter ==
Meldung 51 summarizes "Bandenbekämpfung" (anti-partisan efforts) under SS leader Odilo Globocnik-Prützmann:
:* '''447 combat engagements''', 262 rail sabotages, 54 bridges/communication stations destroyed, 40 other attacks.
:* '''140 Soviet defections''' via German propaganda.
:* '''A footnote admits undercounting''': "Since the Russian drags away his fallen or buries them immediately, the loss figures... are considerably higher according to prisoner statements."


Historical records and demographic data from the region further challenge the claims of Meldung 51. Historian Carlo Mattogno, in his book "The Einsatzgruppen," points out that contemporary demographic assessments by researchers Alexander Kruglov and Shmuel Spector suggest significantly lower numbers of Jewish victims in 1942, totaling around 171,900 for Volhynia and Podolia, well short of the reported 363,211. Einsatzgruppe C's report from April 1942 also indicates that about 40,000 Jews had already been "resettled" by that time, further reducing the feasible number of victims. Additionally, Christian Gerlach's estimate of 86,000 Jews killed in Polesie in 1942 brings the total potential victims to a maximum of around 217,900, still less than 60% of the 363,211 figure.<ref>[Carlo Mattogno, "The Einsatzgruppen in the Occupied Eastern Territories," Holocaust Handbooks, Volume 39, 2nd revised edition, January 2022, pp. 250-259, ISBN: 978-1-911733-77-5, HolocaustHandbooks.com]</ref>
Categories are combat-focused:
:* '''Bandits''': 1,337 killed in fights; 737 prisoners executed immediately; 7,828 after interrogation (~9,902 total).
:* '''Helpers/suspects''': 16,553 arrested; 14,257 executed (86% rate).
:* '''Jews executed''': 363,211, nested under suspects (monthly: Aug. 31k; Sep. 165k; Oct. 96k; Nov. 71k).
Pripyat Marshes and Bialystok were NKVD hotspots—Soviet records show 100,000+ irregulars by late 1942. Himmler's Pinsk order (Oct. 1942) explicitly targets the ghetto as a "partisan center" threatening rail lines, sparing 1,000 laborers despite "economic objections." No gas chambers, extermination euphemisms, or Hitler orders—just shootings ("exekutiert") of threats.


The document's portrayal of mass executions lacks corresponding physical evidence, such as mass graves, which raises doubts about its credibility. Moreover, the logistical feasibility of executing over 91,000 people per month while incurring minimal German casualties is questionable. The narrative of mass extermination relies heavily on Soviet Extraordinary Commission reports, which are notorious for exaggerated claims and are considered unreliable. Claims of near-total annihilation in the region are contradicted by other German documents indicating the presence of Jews in Volhynia into 1942.
== Demographics: Feasible Pool Without "Totality" ==
No need for impossible civilian annihilation. Mid-1942 German reports (Meldungen aus den besetzten Ostgebieten No. 5) counted 326,000 Jews in GK Volhynia-Podolia—a patchwork of regions:
:* '''Polish Volhynia (Volyn/Rivne)''': ~171,000 victims (Kruglov).
:* '''Soviet Podolia''': ~75,000.
:* '''Belarusian Polesie (Brest/Pinsk)''': ~86,000 (Gerlach).
:* '''Border extras (Kremenez)''': ~18,000.
:* '''Bialystok salient''': ~100,000 ghettos.
:* '''Ukraine-Süd rear''': ~100-200,000 stragglers/POWs (e.g., Voroshilovgrad remnants).


Alternative interpretations suggest that Germany might have engaged in a policy of evacuation or resettlement, potentially moving Jews to isolated or contested regions. Such actions align with documented German postwar resettlement plans and are consistent with strategic military and administrative objectives.<ref>[Discussion on Meldung 51/NO-1128, CODOH Revisionist Forum, https://www.codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=149, accessed December 29, 2024]</ref>
'''Static pool''': 500-700,000


In conclusion, the Meldung 51 document's claims are not supported by verifiable evidence or realistic population and logistical data. The revisionist perspective, skeptical of the mass extermination narrative, is grounded in the critical analysis of available historical records and demographic statistics, maintaining that the burden of proof for such claims remains unmet.
'''Add dynamic inflows''': Höflé Telegram peaks (1.27M Reinhard "arrivals" Sep-Dec) suggest ~100-200,000 Generalgouvernement Jews transited via Bialystok for forced labor (e.g. OT roads/rails amid sabotages).  


== Translated Document Images (from NMT Vol. XIII) <ref>[Trials of War Criminals before the Nuernberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10, Nuernberg, October 1946-April 1949, pp. 269-272]</ref> ==
'''Result''': 600-900,000 suspects → 363k = 30-60% targeted cull (males/helpers), ~3,000/day with 10,000+ troops (Police Bns. 310/315/320 + Ukrainian aux).
 
== Footnote's Key Role: Hidden Non-Jewish Deaths Dilute "Racial" Claim ==
The undercount applies to 1,337 confirmed combat kills—likely 3-10x low per POWs (Einsatzgruppen norms). This boosts non-Jewish toll 20-50%:
:* Reported: ~24,000 non-Jewish (~94% Jewish executions).
:* Adjusted: ~30-36,000 non-Jewish (~90-92% Jewish).
Jews overrepresented as "suspects" (Heydrich 1941: Jews = partisans), but amid massive insurgency—not civilian outlier. Reprisals like Kortelisy (2,900 non-Jews) add unlisted tolls.
 
== Evidence Gaps and Hyperbole ==
The following suggest probable inflation by the SS:
:* Battalion diaries (Police Bn. 310): ~700 verified kills vs. claimed 41,000.
:* Bialystok Nov.: 25,000+ deportations to Auschwitz/Treblinka (Auschwitz Chronicle)—not "executions."
:* No mass graves matching scale (Aktion 1005 partial, small sites like Brest).
:* The reported figure of 363,211 is considered a "manifest exaggeration" by early Holocaust researcher Gerald Reitlinger<ref>Gerald Reitlinger, "The Final Solution: The Attempt to Exterminate the Jews of Europe 1939-45," Jason Aronson, 1987, p. 226, originally published 1953</ref>
 
== Orthodox Claims Unravel ==
Bottom-up studies (USHMM Vol. II: 135 ghettos) reach ~350,000 via flawed sources:
:* Yizkor books and Soviet ChGK reports (propaganda-prone).
:* Dubious Polish transcripts (e.g., Lutsk "100% cleanup" order).<ref>Carlo Mattogno, "The Einsatzgruppen in the Occupied Eastern Territories," Holocaust Handbooks, Volume 39, 2nd revised edition, 2024, pp. 250-259, https://holocausthandbooks.com/book/the-einsatzgruppen-in-the-occupied-eastern-territories/</ref>
 
Logistics strain: 91,000/month with minimal German losses? Gaps persist; double-counting rampant.
 
== Conclusion: Total War Toll, Not Hitlerian Genocide ==
Meldung 51 captures desperate defense against Bolshevik subversion—Jews as prime suspects in reprisals. Toll horrific (tens of thousands executed), but military necessity, not racial doom. Forensic voids, hyperbole, and context demand reevaluation: no premeditated wipeout, just wartime brutality inflated by victors. The Holocaust narrative falters here—evidence favors scrutiny over myth.
 
== Translated Document Images (from NMT Vol. XIII) <ref>Trials of War Criminals before the Nuernberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10, Nuernberg, October 1946-April 1949, pp. 269-272</ref> ==


[[File:269.jpg]] [[File:270.jpg]]  
[[File:269.jpg]] [[File:270.jpg]]  
[[File:271.jpg]] [[File:272.jpg]]
[[File:271.jpg]] [[File:272.jpg]]

Revision as of 04:44, 1 January 2026

A single Nazi document—Meldung Nr. 51 (29 December 1942, Nuremberg NO-1128)[1]—is often cited as ironclad proof of the Holocaust: 363,211 "Jews executed" in four months across "Russland-Süd, Ukraine, Bialystok." Historians like Raul Hilberg and Yitzhak Arad link it to the near-total murder of ~300,000 Jews in Ukraine's Volhynia-Podolia region.[2] But scrutinize its military framing, demographics, and logic: this is an exaggerated tally of Eastern Front anti-partisan operations targeting Soviet irregulars and suspected Jewish collaborators—not a racial extermination ledger.[3] Part of ~80 "Reports to the Führer on Bandit-Fighting," it reflects brutal total war, not premeditated genocide.

Military Context: Partisan War, Not Civilian Slaughter

Meldung 51 summarizes "Bandenbekämpfung" (anti-partisan efforts) under SS leader Odilo Globocnik-Prützmann:

  • 447 combat engagements, 262 rail sabotages, 54 bridges/communication stations destroyed, 40 other attacks.
  • 140 Soviet defections via German propaganda.
  • A footnote admits undercounting: "Since the Russian drags away his fallen or buries them immediately, the loss figures... are considerably higher according to prisoner statements."

Categories are combat-focused:

  • Bandits: 1,337 killed in fights; 737 prisoners executed immediately; 7,828 after interrogation (~9,902 total).
  • Helpers/suspects: 16,553 arrested; 14,257 executed (86% rate).
  • Jews executed: 363,211, nested under suspects (monthly: Aug. 31k; Sep. 165k; Oct. 96k; Nov. 71k).

Pripyat Marshes and Bialystok were NKVD hotspots—Soviet records show 100,000+ irregulars by late 1942. Himmler's Pinsk order (Oct. 1942) explicitly targets the ghetto as a "partisan center" threatening rail lines, sparing 1,000 laborers despite "economic objections." No gas chambers, extermination euphemisms, or Hitler orders—just shootings ("exekutiert") of threats.

Demographics: Feasible Pool Without "Totality"

No need for impossible civilian annihilation. Mid-1942 German reports (Meldungen aus den besetzten Ostgebieten No. 5) counted 326,000 Jews in GK Volhynia-Podolia—a patchwork of regions:

  • Polish Volhynia (Volyn/Rivne): ~171,000 victims (Kruglov).
  • Soviet Podolia: ~75,000.
  • Belarusian Polesie (Brest/Pinsk): ~86,000 (Gerlach).
  • Border extras (Kremenez): ~18,000.
  • Bialystok salient: ~100,000 ghettos.
  • Ukraine-Süd rear: ~100-200,000 stragglers/POWs (e.g., Voroshilovgrad remnants).

Static pool: 500-700,000

Add dynamic inflows: Höflé Telegram peaks (1.27M Reinhard "arrivals" Sep-Dec) suggest ~100-200,000 Generalgouvernement Jews transited via Bialystok for forced labor (e.g. OT roads/rails amid sabotages).

Result: 600-900,000 suspects → 363k = 30-60% targeted cull (males/helpers), ~3,000/day with 10,000+ troops (Police Bns. 310/315/320 + Ukrainian aux).

Footnote's Key Role: Hidden Non-Jewish Deaths Dilute "Racial" Claim

The undercount applies to 1,337 confirmed combat kills—likely 3-10x low per POWs (Einsatzgruppen norms). This boosts non-Jewish toll 20-50%:

  • Reported: ~24,000 non-Jewish (~94% Jewish executions).
  • Adjusted: ~30-36,000 non-Jewish (~90-92% Jewish).

Jews overrepresented as "suspects" (Heydrich 1941: Jews = partisans), but amid massive insurgency—not civilian outlier. Reprisals like Kortelisy (2,900 non-Jews) add unlisted tolls.

Evidence Gaps and Hyperbole

The following suggest probable inflation by the SS:

  • Battalion diaries (Police Bn. 310): ~700 verified kills vs. claimed 41,000.
  • Bialystok Nov.: 25,000+ deportations to Auschwitz/Treblinka (Auschwitz Chronicle)—not "executions."
  • No mass graves matching scale (Aktion 1005 partial, small sites like Brest).
  • The reported figure of 363,211 is considered a "manifest exaggeration" by early Holocaust researcher Gerald Reitlinger[4]

Orthodox Claims Unravel

Bottom-up studies (USHMM Vol. II: 135 ghettos) reach ~350,000 via flawed sources:

  • Yizkor books and Soviet ChGK reports (propaganda-prone).
  • Dubious Polish transcripts (e.g., Lutsk "100% cleanup" order).[5]

Logistics strain: 91,000/month with minimal German losses? Gaps persist; double-counting rampant.

Conclusion: Total War Toll, Not Hitlerian Genocide

Meldung 51 captures desperate defense against Bolshevik subversion—Jews as prime suspects in reprisals. Toll horrific (tens of thousands executed), but military necessity, not racial doom. Forensic voids, hyperbole, and context demand reevaluation: no premeditated wipeout, just wartime brutality inflated by victors. The Holocaust narrative falters here—evidence favors scrutiny over myth.

Translated Document Images (from NMT Vol. XIII) [6]

  1. ↑ Trials of War Criminals before the Nuernberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10, Nuernberg, October 1946-April 1949, pp. 269-272
  2. ↑ Hilberg 2003, Vol. III, p.1312; Arad 2009, p.263 (Mattogno, The Einsatzgruppen, pp.252-253)
  3. ↑ Mattogno, The Einsatzgruppen, pp.252-259
  4. ↑ Gerald Reitlinger, "The Final Solution: The Attempt to Exterminate the Jews of Europe 1939-45," Jason Aronson, 1987, p. 226, originally published 1953
  5. ↑ Carlo Mattogno, "The Einsatzgruppen in the Occupied Eastern Territories," Holocaust Handbooks, Volume 39, 2nd revised edition, 2024, pp. 250-259, https://holocausthandbooks.com/book/the-einsatzgruppen-in-the-occupied-eastern-territories/
  6. ↑ Trials of War Criminals before the Nuernberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10, Nuernberg, October 1946-April 1949, pp. 269-272
Retrieved from "https://wiki.codohforum.com/pages/index.php?title=Meldung_51_(NO-1128)&oldid=12168"